Fat Orange Cat Brew Company & Nightmare Brewing

Our Rating


RateBeer Rating
BeerGraph's proprietary measure of a beer's quality, or Beers Above Replacement (BAR), has been converted from a scale of -5-20 to 0-100.


Beer stats from RateBeer
Beer stats from RateBeer
category-iconBeer Reviews

Feed Me a Stray Cat Is a Beer That Patrick Bateman Would Love

May 18, 2020

By Jay C. Williams, May 18, 2020

Breweries often stick to certain motifs in their products and branding. Some take style cues from musical genres, science or Greek mythology. But what happens when two very different breweries collaborate? Specifically, what if one is feline-inspired and the other is a death metal- and horror-themed brewery? Where do they find common ground? At the movies! 

Connecticut’s Fat Orange Cat Brew Company and New York’s Nightmare Brewing found a creative nexus in the satirical thriller American Psycho. In the film about a yuppie serial killer, there’s a scene in which an ATM tells the titular psycho to feed it a stray cat—thus the inspiration for this beer’s name. The label for Feed Me a Stray Cat, a double dry-hopped triple IPA, features a panel for each brewery’s interpretation of the macabre movie. 

The beer’s appearance is a hazy yellow with a white head that causes some lacing on the glass. A first whiff has sticky aromas of ripe pineapple, papaya, and orange. There are some underlying bready notes, too.

It’s got a full-bodied mouthfeel just shy of being thick, with some creaminess to boot. The first sip has citrus-tropical sweetness followed by a pronounced bitterness like orange pith. (You might find yourself making a face like Marlon Brando in The Godfather.) There’s definitely a malty backbone here. Since it’s a triple IPA, the 10% ABV comes as no surprise. However, this isn’t a “ninja beer” where the alcohol sneaks up on you—there’s a bit of a warming effect after each sip. The aftertaste is sticky, with some fruit and a little herbaceousness. 

Feed Me a Stray Cat is a bold and balanced triple IPA. It’s a nice beer, but I don’t recommend drinking more than one, lest you might start taking bad advice from ATMs.

ZX Ventures, a division within AB InBev, is an investor in October
Related Articles

Russian River’s Consecration Is Perfect

The dark ale aged in Cabernet barrels layers on the flavors in a way worthy of top marks.

Stout Season Is Off to the Races with AleSmith’s Speedway Stout

Slow down with surprising stout that adds a bit of fruity tanginess to the rich and boozy style.

All You Need Is a Hammock and a Hypebiscus

Sankofa Beer Company’s flagship pale ale is more of a hammock beer than a lawnmower beer.